2010년 2월 24일 수요일

What I want to hear in the Toyota hearing

In the Toyota hearing, as an engineer, I want to hear what is really the cause and how to fix, if they can fix? Do they know the cause?

The sudden unexpected acceleration problem has been reported for a long time in many different countries with many different car makers. No one was able to pinpoint the cause. I remember that Sixty Minutes in CBS had a special report about a decade or so ago.

The pattern has been that the car makers always deny the existence of such sudden unexpected acceleration. At this time, Toyota got caught. Toyota hurried up and recalled the cars to replace the brake. The question is: was it the brake? My intuition as an engineer tells me it is NOT the brake. It should be something else.

Let's face it. If it is brake, we are limiting this as a mechanical issue. Mechnical issue is easy to pinpoint and fix. However, if it is, why in the world there are so many cases reported around the world and the car makers denied the existence of the problem for more than a decade? It is something more complicated than this. I suspect Toyota wanted to view this as a mechanical issue and recalled. I have been wondered if the replacement would solve the problem. It may NOT be that easy.

Yesterday, they confessed that they are not sure that this recall would fix the problem. The head of Toyota sales in the US said that the company's big recalls may "not totally" solve unintended acceleration problems. Aha! They do not know.

They said they will install the "Smart Brake," which is designed to stop the car if both the pedals of acceleration and brake get applied. Uhh? This becomes even more strange. What if the unexpected acceleration occurs even if both pedals are not applied? To me, "Smart Brake" is only a temporary fix that might not solve all the cases. Without knowing what the problem is, this "Smart Brake" would NOT be taken seriously. Simply, it is NOT the solution solving the problem entirely.

My engineer's intuition tells me this must be an eletronic issue. It might NOT be an isolated electronic component but be a number of components.

From the hearing, I want to hear the evidences why they think it is NOT an electronic problem. I have not heard that yet.

댓글 없음:

댓글 쓰기